Carrah Fisk Hennessey starred on the soccer pitch and softball diamond for Keene State are it transitioned to NCAA Division III and Little East Conference membership for the 1997-98 academic year. The 1999 LEC Softball Player of the Year was an all-conference and National Fastpitch Coaches Association (NFCA) All-Region selection in each of her two LEC seasons; for her career, Fisk Hennessey was a four-time all-conference and three-time NFCA All-Region pick.
She led the Owls to the 1999 LEC regular season and tournament titles on their way to a berth in the NCAA Northeast Region Championship Final and a then program-record 33 wins. Fisk Hennessey led Division III with a program-record 16 homeruns as a senior, a record that still stands to this day. She additionally holds the single-season (.916) and career (.633) slugging percentage records and total bases in a season (120), and remains in the top-10 for most single-season and career offensive categories.
Fisk Hennessey would also develop into and All-LEC goalkeeper for the women’s soccer program. She was named a Second-Team All-LEC performer as a senior, winning a then-program-record 16 games while leading the Owls to a LEC title and berth in the NCAA Division III Championship Tournament.
Fisk Hennessy just completed her fourth season (2018) as head softball coach at her alma mater after coaching soccer and softball and serving as assistant athletic director at New England College.